Share or save this article

Share on X

AUDIO

Listen to this article

3:48

日本語

Checking your sign-in status…

An audio edition based on this article.

Why “coffee got a little cheaper” is not the whole story

News that coffee prices have fallen may suggest that cafés will pay less for beans and charge less per cup. But the market in October 2026 required a closer look. According to the International Coffee Organization’s (ICO) monthly report, the ICO Composite Indicator Price (I-CIP), an international benchmark, averaged 261.26 US cents per pound. That was down 0.3% from the previous month.[1]

The indicator combines market prices for different types of green coffee: beans that have yet to be roasted and brewed. It does not represent the price on a café’s purchasing invoice. Actual purchase prices vary with bean type, origin, quality, transportation, exchange rates, and contract terms.

The components also moved in opposite directions that month. The three main Arabica groups rose from the previous month, while Robusta fell. The single word “coffee” encompasses different markets. That raises the central question: why can bean type change a business decision even when the average barely moves?

Four prices reveal the differences

The ICO publishes green coffee price indicators for several groups. The table below sets out their October 2026 averages and changes from the previous month.[1]

| ICO coffee group | October average price (US cents/pound) | Change from previous month | |---|---:|---:| | Colombian Milds | 357.85 | +0.5% | | Other Milds | 334.99 | +1.7% | | Brazilian Naturals | 294.49 | +1.5% | | Robustas | 164.19 | -2.0% | | Composite indicator I-CIP | 261.26 | -0.3% |

It would also be a mistake to assume that all Arabica costs the same. The indicators distinguish between origins, quality, and processing methods. Colombian Milds and Brazilian Naturals, for example, are both Arabica groups, but their prices differ. Robusta is a different species, with different flavors and uses. Which indicator matters to a café depends on the beans it normally buys.

The unit matters too. “US cents per pound” is an international price benchmark based on bean weight, not a retail price per cup. One pound is approximately 454 grams, but the measure does not account for weight changes during roasting, brewing yield, or waste. The reported price should not be translated directly into the cost of a cup of coffee.

Why Arabica rose while Robusta fell

The ICO’s October 2026 report explained that tight stocks certified by exchanges helped support Arabica prices. US certified Arabica stocks fell from 260,000 bags at the end of September to 230,000 bags at the end of October. These are the month-end figures given in the report. They do not mean that these were the only stocks available worldwide.[1]

For Robusta, by contrast, certified stocks in London rose from 870,000 bags at the end of September to 1,130,000 bags at the end of October. The report also cited the progressing harvest in Vietnam and a 15.7% year-over-year increase in September green Robusta exports as factors pointing toward greater supply.[1]

The basic mechanism is simple: when many buyers want beans but few are available for immediate delivery, prices are less likely to fall. Conversely, when more beans reach the market, prices are more likely to fall. But these factors alone do not determine prices. Exchange rates, transportation, futures market expectations, weather in producing regions, and quality differences also matter. The ICO itself pointed to several such factors in October.

| Conditions that make prices more likely to rise | Conditions that make prices more likely to fall | |---|---| | Limited stocks of the required quality | More stocks available for shipment | | Growing concerns about future supply | Harvests and exports progressing smoothly | | Strong demand for that type of bean | Buyers holding back on purchases |

This table provides a framework for understanding market direction. None of these conditions is a rule that invariably moves prices. To understand what was observed that month, the framework needs to be read alongside the ICO’s specific stock and export figures.

The average price calculation had also changed

The report contains another easily overlooked fact. On October 1, 2026, the ICO changed the weights assigned to each coffee group in its composite indicator. According to the report, the change lowered the October 1 indicator by 2.48 US cents per pound compared with the old weights.[1]

Weights determine which prices count toward an average and how much influence each has. Think of school grades: the average changes depending on whether Japanese and math scores count equally or math counts twice. Even when individual prices stay the same, changing the calculation can change the average.

October’s 0.3% decline in the composite indicator therefore cannot be attributed entirely to beans becoming cheaper. Changes in market prices must be distinguished from changes in the indicator’s calculation. This distinction matters whenever an index informs business decisions, in coffee and elsewhere.

Which figures should a small café watch?

Consider a café that mainly uses Arabica beans. If it sees the industry average falling and expects cheaper supplies next month, its supplier’s actual price may differ from that expectation. Arabica indicators have risen, and the final price also depends on when the contract was signed and on transportation costs.

The café should first check its beans’ type and origin, and which period’s prices its procurement contract reflects. It should then break down the actual amount billed into items such as beans, transportation, roasting, waste, and labor costs. Only then can it consider whether to change its price per cup. International indicators provide context; they do not automatically set the café’s menu prices.

For another café that uses Robusta in its blends, the effect could run in a different direction even in the same October. But increasing the share of Robusta does not necessarily increase profit. Changing a blend without considering taste preferences, brand promises, the quality of beans sourced, and existing customers’ reactions could reduce sales even if ingredient costs fall.

First, examine what is happening in international indicators. Next, compare those movements with the business’s beans and contracts. Finally, check actual gross profit and the customer experience. Connecting market data with running a café requires these three steps.

Can the average price alone be enough?

The composite indicator is useful for a broad view of industry trends. It combines prices for many types of coffee into one figure that can be compared over time. But relying on the average alone for procurement decisions becomes riskier when different groups move in opposite directions or the indicator’s weights change, as happened here.

The relationship between October’s inventory and prices presented here is not an experiment establishing a single cause. The ICO outlines supply and inventory conditions, but trading conditions and changing expectations also influence prices. The analysis concerns green coffee in international markets. It does not directly measure monthly costs, consumption tax, currency hedging, or rent movements at Japanese stores. Retail prices do not necessarily change the day after international prices move.

FORWARD BASIS’s view: Break down averages and use them, rather than dismiss them

The lesson from the coffee market in October 2026 is not that average prices are useless. An average is a useful starting point for understanding the market. But a small decline in the average is not the same as a fall in the price you pay for beans. The figures make sense only when rising Arabica prices, falling Robusta prices, differences in inventory, and changes in the indicator’s weights are considered together.

FORWARD BASIS proposes this sequence for making decisions: look at the average → examine the breakdown → connect it to your own terms of trade. This approach extends beyond coffee to indexes that combine multiple costs, such as electricity, groceries, and labor. First, use a single figure to grasp the overall picture, then break it down into the parts relevant to your decision. That extra step makes the difference between knowing information and using it.

SOURCE

Sources

These are the primary sources we used to check the facts. The article identifies our own analysis.

  1. Sourcehttps://www.ico.org/documents/cy2026-27/cmr-1026-e.pdf
  2. Sourcehttps://ico.org/resources/public-market-information/
  3. Sourcehttps://ico.org/resources/coffee-market-report-statistics-section/
NEXT BASIS
More in Business →
Business2026.11.14About 7.6 min read READ

Revenue Down 12%, Operating Profit Up 49%: Why Console Unit Sales Alone Cannot Explain Nintendo’s Business

Nintendo’s interim financial results on November 5, 2026, showed that profit rose even as console unit sales fell. However, software’s share of sales was not the only factor. Understanding the profit increase requires distinguishing its drivers, including a one-time factor: US tariff refunds.

Business2026.11.14About 5.3 min read READ

Does Costco’s 10% Revenue Growth Mean Customers Bought 10% More? Separating Gasoline, Exchange Rates, and Gross Profit

In fiscal 2026, Costco increased net sales from merchandise and other sales by about 10% from the previous year. That looks like solid performance for a membership warehouse retailer. But revenue reflects more than the volume customers bought. It also reflects gasoline prices, exchange rates used to convert overseas revenue into dollars, and the impact of adding stores. When revenue grows, what should we conclude has increased? We break down the company’s official US financial results.[1][2]

Business2026.11.13About 5.0 min read READ

Subscriptions Generate 96% of Adobe’s Revenue. That Does Not Necessarily Mean a Stable Business—Read Three Earnings Metrics Separately

In Adobe’s fiscal 2025 financial results, subscription revenue was approximately $22.904 billion out of total revenue of approximately $23.769 billion—about 96%. But a high share of recurring revenue is not the same as retaining customers. Assessing the business’s strength requires reading revenue, ARR, and contracted future revenue separately.